Thanksgiving Dinner

topic posted Thu, November 15, 2007 - 9:50 AM by  quel qu'un
Share/Save/Bookmark
What is your typical Thanksgiving menu? Do you host? How did you decide on what it would be and does it change from year to year?
Finally, what do those foods symbolize for you and your loved ones?
posted by:
quel qu'un
Los Angeles
  • Re: Thanksgiving Dinner

    Thu, November 15, 2007 - 11:03 AM
    My family rotates hosting Easter/Thanksgiving/Christmas each year. It's funny how acutely certain foods will stir memories and feelings of togetherness. My family does the "Normal Rockwell" dinner; turkey, stuffing, gravy, etc. etc. But there are a couple of dishes that really make the meal. One is a green jello salad that is made with pineapple, cottage cheese and nuts... it just isn't a family gathering without this specific green jello salad. Even more telling is the absence of the carrot-and-raisin salad since my grandmother passed away... nobody makes it the same, so we don't even try.
    • Re: Thanksgiving Dinner

      Thu, November 15, 2007 - 8:57 PM
      My gramma's signature dishes were the cranberry sauce and pea salad, a cold salad made with peas, diced onion, diced hard-boiled egg, and a mustard/mayo-based dressing. Not everyone liked the pea salad as much as I did, and I miss it since she passed.
      I did learn from her how to make whole-fruit cranberry sauce (it's really dead easy!) at an early age, however, so I take care of that now.
      Oh, and pumpkin pie is absolutely required! That was a Mom/Gramma combined effort. I only crave it around this time of year, so I learned how to make it by the time I went to college, and I now make basically my gramma's recipe, plus extra spices. :)
      Oh, the other required food at every Thanksgiving and Christmas dinner are my aunt's recipe: butter horn rolls. I haven't quite mastered them like my mom has, but I'm still working on it. They're pretty time-consuming, though: you have to make the dough the night before and let it rise, then roll them out and let them rise again...but they're SO worth it, especially with some of my mom's homemade berry jam smeared on them while still hot. :)
  • Re: Thanksgiving Dinner

    Thu, November 15, 2007 - 1:17 PM
    our typical thanksgiving consists of whatever people want to bring. its always a potluck and since the group is a combination of family and chosen family (and some people who have nowhere else to go). I always make the mashed potatoes and gravy, though most of the time i make a batch of regular and then a batch of some crazy new recipe ive found. mom is in charge of the turkey, my siblings set the table and beat eachother and stay out of the kitchen (its better that way). we try to get people to call ahead and let us know what theyre going to bring so we make sure that there is a good spread over the food groups, but

    we always end up with too many desserts.

    but its always a ton of fun and since we have a rotating crowd we get a mix of everyones family traditions
    and they ALL are tasty!
    • Re: Thanksgiving Dinner

      Thu, November 15, 2007 - 1:31 PM
      Our Thanksgivings are like Wish's: My mom hosts, typically, two dozen people, few of whom we share DNA with, and everyone brings something. She does the turkey, the scalloped oysters (yuck), stuffing, and smashies. Everything else is potucked. This year I'm doing onions in cream sauce but I have done sweet potato and pecan pies, smashies, roasted pears, and green beans.

      Since huzzleban came into our lives, we also have "the green stuff" mentioned above and banana pudding. He's also done "the pink stuff" but we've moved on from that, thank goodness (strawberry Jell-O powder + Cool Whip + slivered almonds).

      In 1978 my mother prepared a ham and she STILL hasn't lived it down. Even our vegetarian immigrant friend still gives her a bad time about serving ham on Thanksgiving.
  • Re: Thanksgiving Dinner

    Thu, November 15, 2007 - 3:14 PM
    There are certain things that always mean thanksgiving to me: turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing, sweet potatoes and pumpkin pie. Everything else is up for negotiation. I feel strongly that if there's some food that make thanksgiving for you, then make sure it's included in the meal. When I host, I specifically asked people if there were certain things they really wanted included.

    This year we're going to a friend's house and it's an organized potluck. I'll be making homemade cranberry sauce, my killer sweet potatoes and roasted chestnut stuffing. I'm relieved, since for the previous three years, I did almost all of the cooking myself. Since it's been for a smaller groups I've opted to make a large turkey breast instead of a whole bird, which worked really well. Anyone in need of a good turkey breast recipe - this one is wonderful.

    Wild Mushroom Stuffed Turkey Breast with Cranberry Coulis
    www.foodnetwork.com/food/rec...8,00.html
  • Re: Thanksgiving Dinner

    Thu, November 15, 2007 - 4:06 PM
    I agree with most of the other posters -- the fundamentals are turkey, cranberry, dressing, potatoes, sweet potatoes. My mom makes the most wonderful giblet gravy that I love the most and no other gravy is like mom's. I used to go to my college roommate's in Minnesota and her mom added squash and wild rice, YUM. My aunt in Florida (where I'm going this year) is making kugel especially for me since I loved it so much the last time I was there.

    How about dessert? My mom's traditionally is pumpkin pie. My uncle goes to the store and buys all the fruit pies that look good, and maybe a chocolate cream or something too. And the friend in MN's family buys a selection of pints of ice cream and sorbet. We couldn't leave the table until we tried each flavor -- UGH but YUMMY!!
  • Re: Thanksgiving Dinner

    Thu, November 15, 2007 - 6:56 PM
    my menu is very traditional
    turkey
    gravy
    mashed potatoes
    stuffing
    green bean casserole
    biscuits
    sweet potato casserole
    pumpkin pie

    the one food that symbolizes the holiday for me is one i don't make myself. my mom makes it. it is a jell-o mold that has whole cranberry suace, choped celery, crushed pineapple and a few other items in it. believe it or not we eat it with mayo. sort of reminds me of waldorf salad, only in jell-o form. gotta have it or it ain't T-Day.

    this year i'm only cooking for a few folks so i'm switching it up a bit
    turkey
    gravy
    stuffing
    roasted root vegetables
    green bean casserole
    baby green salad with pears, goat chees and candied pecans
    individual baked alaskas for dessert
    and of course mom is making that salad =]

Recent topics in "Recipe Exchange"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Dips? Mr. M 38 Today, 1:21 PM
It's Friut Salad Season! Survivor 10 Yesterday, 11:27 AM
Strawberry Shortcake fixit fox 6 Yesterday, 10:59 AM
Got Extra? Call your local food pantry... Donna 3 Yesterday, 10:34 AM